Invite People

Share 4Engineers with your friends and help them get started!

Emails
Enter multiple email addresses by separating it with a comma.
Back

304 vs 316 vs duplex on chloride washdown packaging frames: run the PREN before you pick

304
316
Duplex or higher
Coated carbon steel or other
Login to vote

2 votes  ·  Single choice

Pitting on packaging frames in washdown areas is usually a chloride problem, not a "stainless isn't stainless" problem. A quick first screen is the pitting resistance equivalent number, PREN = %Cr + 3.3 × %Mo + 16 × %N. Typical ranges are about 18–20 for 304, about 23–28 for 316, and about 35 for duplex 2205. Higher means more resistance to chloride pitting at a given temperature and chloride level.

PREN is a ranking tool, not a design rule. Crevices under bolted brackets, guards, and gaskets, stagnant films that dry and concentrate chloride, and chlorinated sanitizers at elevated temperature can all pit a grade that looks fine on paper. Design details (open frames, sealed tube ends, sloped surfaces, no lap joints) often do more than an alloy upgrade. What do you run on frames that see daily chlorinated washdown?

Poll: What's on your washdown-area machine frames?

Login to comment

Login
Report content
Reason Description