Invite People

Share 4Engineers with your friends and help them get started!

Emails
Enter multiple email addresses by separating it with a comma.
Back

The 10/13 rule: when tube rupture stops being a relief case

Design the low side to meet 10/13
Relief device sized for the rupture case
Dynamic analysis to justify
Case by case
Login to vote

2 votes  ·  Single choice

API Standard 521 lets you skip tube rupture as a relief case for a shell-and-tube exchanger when the low-pressure side's corrected hydrotest pressure is at least the high-pressure side's design pressure. Since ASME Section VIII now hydrotests at 1.3 times design pressure, that means a low-side design pressure of at least 10/13 (about 77%) of the high-side design pressure. This replaced the old two-thirds rule from when hydrotests were at 1.5 times design.

In practice, the low-pressure side includes everything the rupture flow can reach: the channel or shell, the connected piping, and any downstream equipment you can't isolate. Raising one exchanger's design pressure doesn't help if a lower-rated drum sits downstream. When the rule isn't met, the relief device has to handle a fast transient, especially with gas or flashing liquid on the high side. That's why rupture disks are common in this service and why a dynamic analysis is worth considering.

Poll: For new exchangers, how do you usually handle tube rupture?

Login to comment

Login
Report content
Reason Description