Invite People

Share 4Engineers with your friends and help them get started!

Emails
Enter multiple email addresses by separating it with a comma.
Back

Thermal relief on a blocked-in exchanger: when 3/4 x 1 is not enough

3/4 x 1 by default, no calc
Calculated per 4.4.12.3 every time
Calculated only for large liquid-full exchangers
Locked-open block valves instead of a PRD
Login to vote

2 votes  ·  Single choice

API 521 (7th ed., 4.4.12.2) says a DN 20 x DN 25 (NPS 3/4 x NPS 1) relief valve is commonly used for hydraulic expansion. The same clause sends you to 4.4.12.3 if there's reason to doubt that size. 4.4.12.3 then names two cases where a larger device can be required: long, large-bore uninsulated aboveground lines, and large vessels or exchangers operating liquid-full.

The rate check is quick. Equation (2) in 4.4.12.3:
q = αv × Φ / (1000 × d × c)
q is in m3/s, αv in 1/°C, Φ in W (for an exchanger, the maximum operating duty), d is relative density and c is in J/kg·K.

Take a 2 MW exchanger blocked in on the cold side.
Water: αv = 0.00018 1/°C (Table 2), d = 1.0, c = 4180 J/kg·K. q = 8.6e-5 m3/s, about 1.4 gpm.
40 °API hydrocarbon: αv = 0.0009 1/°C (Table 2), d about 0.82, c about 2100 J/kg·K. q = 1.05e-3 m3/s, about 17 gpm.

Same duty, roughly 12 times the relief rate. A 3/4 x 1 valve handles 1.4 gpm easily. At 17 gpm, run the API 520 liquid sizing against the actual orifice area of the valve being bought.

Two cautions in the same section are easy to miss. First, if the trapped liquid can heat past its bubble point at relief pressure, the small valve is no longer enough and the case moves to 4.4.13.2.5.3. Second, 4.4.12.2 says the set pressure must never be above the rating of the weakest component in the blocked-in system. 4.4.12.1 does allow locked-open cold-side block valves under administrative control in place of a PRD, but it also warns that isolation valves leak and that a control or shutdown system can block in cold fluid.

Poll: How does your site handle cold-side thermal relief on exchangers?

Login to comment

Login
Report content
Reason Description